Explore Gary, IN Homes for Sale Between $450,000 to $500,000

Homes for Sale in Gary, IN Between $450,000 to $500,000

Advanced Search Market Reports Home Value Connect

Welcome to your dedicated resource for Homes for Sale Between $450,000 to $500,000 in Gary, IN. This page is your live portal for listings that match the exact homes for sale you demand, filtering out irrelevant properties to save you time. As a local Gary, IN agent, Listing Leaders specializes in the unique market dynamics of this area, offering insights into amenities, home values, and investment potential. Start exploring the properties currently available between $450,000 to $500,000 below, or contact a local agent to discuss the details that matters most to your search.

< Back to all Homes for Sale in Gary, IN

Search Gary, IN by Price

All Gary, IN Homes for Sale Between $450,000 to $500,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Live and enjoy the Beach life on Miller Beach. This updated 3 bedroom, 2 bath, 2 car garage home is only 2+ blocks to popular Randolph Beach on Lake Michigan. The home has had extensive work done over the years such as new Bathrooms, Kitchen updated w/stainless appliances, new Roof, new chimney, most of plumbing has been upgraded, 200 Amp electrical panel, remodeled basement, windows dual pane, central air, and much more. Miller Beach has the Indiana National Lake shore on the East and southern portions. Marquette Park is on The West end of the Beach. You can be in Chicago by a short Drive or Take the South Shore Train from the New Miller Station and be downtown in about an hour. Schedule your showing today.

7936 Locust Avenue, Gary

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

JUMBO Townhome in the heart of Miller Beach! This 3 bed, 3 bath townhome with an attached 2 car garage is just steps from Shelby Beach, Flamingo's (AKA "The Bird") and more. This spacious stunner features an open floor plan with new luxury vinyl throughout, high-end quartz countertops in the kitchen and all baths, new lighting throughout, all appliances and plenty of natural light! Bonus features include a spacious laundry room, soaker tub, covered balconies overlooking greenery and well-maintained mechanicals. LOW MAINTENANCE and TURNKEY! Ideal for a second-home or vacation rental yet spacious and functional enough for a primary. Miller is HOT and homes this size, age and condition are rarely available this close to the beach. MOTIVATED SELLER! Bring an offer and start living the #beachlife this summer.

1020 N Shelby Street, Gary

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Summer and Beach Living Are Here! This thoughtfully renovated home offers the chance to experience one of Northwest Indiana's most special lakefront communities. Tucked into a quiet wooded setting near Marquette Park, Miller Beach, and Indiana Dunes National Park, life here is defined by fresh lake breezes, sandy beaches, scenic trails, and the natural beauty of Lake Michigan in every season. Spend mornings walking along the shoreline, afternoons exploring the dunes or nearby parks, and evenings enjoying the vibrant energy of the Miller Beach Arts & Creative District, with its unique shops, dining, and local culture. Inside, the home was fully renovated in 2025, creating a fresh, modern space designed for gathering and relaxation. The open-concept living area features waterproof vinyl plank flooring, abundant natural light, and a welcoming kitchen with stainless steel appliances, breakfast bar, and space to cook, connect, and entertain. Sliding doors extend the living space to an elevated deck perfect for quiet mornings with coffee or evenings with friends. Two main-level bedrooms include a sun-filled primary suite with spa-inspired ensuite bath. The finished lower level provides additional bedrooms, bathroom, and gathering space for guests, recreation, or work-from-home flexibility. Every detail of the home was renovated in 2025 allowing you to move right from closing to living your dream: new mechanicals including tankless water heater, plumbing, roof, windows, and 200-amp electric service. Whether you're looking for a peaceful year-round residence, a weekend escape, or an opportunity for short-term rental income, this location offers flexibility and lifestyle in equal measure while Downtown Chicago remains easily accessible by car or the South Shore Line when the city calls.

7325 Locust Avenue, Gary

Prime commercial development opportunity located along the highly traveled Grant Street corridor in Gary. This B-3 zoned site offers approximately 0.62 acres across multiple parcels, providing flexibility for a wide range of commercial uses. The property was previously improved with a car dealership and restaurant, supporting its strong suitability for retail, restaurant, or automotive-related development. Utilities are available to the site, allowing for a streamlined path toward redevelopment. Surrounded by established national retailers, restaurants, and service-oriented businesses, the location benefits from consistent traffic flow and excellent visibility. The site is well-positioned for high-demand uses such as fast food or drive-thru concepts, subject to City of Gary's approval, making it an attractive opportunity for investors, developers, and owner-users seeking to establish a presence in a proven commercial corridor. Buyers are advised to verify all intended uses with the City of Gary.

3433-39 Grant Street, Gary

6 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths

ATTENTION ATTENTION!!! When I tell you that it's too much to mention, believe us when we say, that this beautiful brick building is loaded with so much useful space. This 3 unit has over 1300 square feet on each level! Each floor has 2 generous sized bedrooms, walk in closets, LR, DR, kitchen, private back porches and a total of 5 3/4 baths. Your search for a multi-unit can be over, with low property taxes! Put this on your schedule and come get this income generating opportunity or move in and live here.

532 Connecticut Street, Gary

ATTENTION ATTENTION!!! When I tell you that it's too much to mention, believe us when we say, that this beautiful brick building is loaded with so much useful space. This 3 unit has over 1300 square feet on each level! Each floor has 2 generous sized bedrooms, walk in closets, LR, DR, kitchen, private back porches and a total of 5 3/4 baths. Your search for a multi-unit can be over, with low property taxes! Put this on your schedule and come get this income generating opportunity or move your family in and live here.

532 Connecticut Street, Gary

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Welcome to the Renowned Marquette Park Community of Miller Beach Offering an Easy Walk to Enjoy the Tranquility and Sandy Beaches of Lake Michigan! Nearby Indiana Dunes National Lake Shore Park Offers a New Adventure Each Visit. Convenience of the South Shore Line Too.Enter this Lovely Custom Built Home & Your Eyes Will Gravitate to the Cathedral Ceiling & ALL the Natural Beautiful Light. THREE Levels of Living Space.....Living Rm is Grand & a Double Sided Fireplace Flows Perfectly Between the Living Rm & Dining Area. Plenty of Cabinetry in the Kitchen & Perfectly Placed Patio Door Exudes Nature with the Main Foor Deck Which is One of Three Deck Areas! Unique Lay Out with a MAIN Floor Bedroom with a FULL Bath.......Primary Bedroom Upstairs (Unless You Prefer the Main Floor Option Just Mentioned) Designed with a Fireplace that Exudes Tranquil Ambience. Spectacular Feathure is the View from the Upper Level to the Main Level. Yet Another Guest Room or Flex Room in Mostly Finished Basement and Yes Another Bathroom with a Shower off this Room. Owner Utilzed Space for a Home Office. The Charm is Really Over the Top....Starting with the Wrap Around Porch at Front Entry w/Lovely View of this Community that Boasts Custom Built & Individual Styles of Homes Making You Feel Like Your Home is Really Special! Your New Backyard is Truly A Daily Reteat of Peace and Appreciation of Nature.....Tons of Lush Greenery Everywhere & an Over the Top Koi Pond w/Sound of Water Flow Will Make You Appreciate Life. Hard to Believe But There are/ 2 More Decks than What Has Already Been Mentioned.....Recreational Space in the Bsmt. in Addition to the Guest/Flex Rm and Bath......Easy Access to Your Garage & Fantastic Convenience of a Door Leading to the Back Yard. Low Indiana Taxes. You Will Be Elated to Just Experience Every day Living in this Home & Will Also Be Honored to Host & Welcome Family & Friends to Enjoy ALL Marquette Park, the Sandy Beaches Of Lake Michigan and NW IN Have to Offer!

739 N Montgomery Street N, Gary

Start Your Search

Updated . Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.